Payroll Compliance Basics Every Small Business Owner Should Understand

 

Source

Incorrect paychecks can create tax mistakes, cost more money to fix, and create more work at year end.

Here are some things to keep in mind when dealing with payroll taxes.

Keep these in mind when dealing with payroll in your US small business that has employees.

What you’ll learn:

  1. Start With Accurate Worker Records
  2. Plan Electronic W-2 Filing Early
  3. Separate Tax Deposits and Returns
  4. Get Hours, Overtime, and Deductions Right
  5. Keep Records You Can Actually Use
  6. Build a Payroll Routine That Catches Mistakes

Start With Accurate Worker Records

When you have someone on payroll, make sure they are classified correctly.

There are many taxes that go with having employees on your payroll vs independent contractors. Just because someone is under a contract does not mean they are not an employee. The IRS can examine the facts to determine if they are an employee or contractor.

This can affect how much you withhold from their paycheck and if you issue a Form W-2 or Form 1099-NEC. If they are considered an employee, most of the time you will have to withhold payroll taxes and issue them a Form W-2 at the end of the year.

Make sure you have the proper legal name, Social Security number, address and W-4 on file for each employee. Their W-4 helps determine how much federal tax to withhold from each paycheck. Don’t forget to have your business EIN on hand as well.

If there are any address or W-4 changes, update them on your books.

Plan Electronic W-2 Filing Early

A W-2 will show the wages paid and taxes withheld for an employee for a calendar year. This will be determined by your payroll records.

You can generate W-2s through payroll or tax software and there are some options to e-file through the Social Security Administration. There are software programs like the AMS tax filing solution that can allow you to complete your W-2 and 1099’s on your desktop and e-file them with an optional add-on. Decide how you want to file your W-2s early.

You may not know about the electronic filing rule. If you file 10 or more information returns in a year, you will most likely need to e-file them. This can include a combination of returns.

You could have 7 W-2s and 4 reportable 1099’s and would need to e-file, even if you didn’t have 10 employees.

You will have to file W-2’s with Social Security and give your employees a copy by February 1st, 2027 for tax year 2026, whether you e-file or file on paper (if allowed).

Filing your W-2 with Social Security and giving your employees a copy are two different things. If you choose to e-deliver your employees their W-2 you will need to obtain their consent and provide the necessary disclosures. Just uploading a file will not provide an employee copy.

Make sure each employee’s name, SSN, and year end wages match your payroll reports. You should also match your year end wages and taxes withheld to your payroll tax returns for the year. Look at any year end adjustments to see if they account for the difference. If you cannot figure out why there is a discrepancy, dig deeper. After you file, check to see if your W-2’s were accepted.

If you filed a W-2 with the incorrect amount of wages or Social Security number, you will most likely have to issue a Form W-2c. Just correcting it on your books will not change the W-2 you filed.

Separate Tax Deposits and Returns

Paying your employees, paying their taxes and reporting those taxes are all different tasks.

There can be several taxes withheld from each paycheck: federal income tax, Social Security, and Medicare taxes. Employers also owe their own payroll taxes. Federal unemployment will usually be paid by the employer and not deducted from the employee’s paycheck.

Once you deduct these amounts from your employees, you cannot use that money for your day to day expenses. You will have to electronically deposit these taxes when due. Most employers are either on a monthly or semi-weekly deposit schedule. Each one has different due dates depending on when you paid your employees.

Just because you deposited those taxes, doesn’t mean you reported them. Most employers will report on a Form 941, which is done quarterly. There are other situations that you may have to file on a different basis.

You may also have to withhold state taxes and pay state unemployment, depending on where your employees live and work.

Have reminders for your payroll taxes when they are due and when you have to report them.

Get Hours, Overtime, and Deductions Right

If your employees are being paid incorrectly, your tax filings may also be inaccurate.

Covered, nonexempt employees generally must be paid at least 1 ½ times their regular rate of pay when they exceed 40 hours in a workweek. There are also state laws that can help with overtime as well.

An employee can be salaried and still be owed overtime if they meet the criteria. Time worked outside a normal schedule, from home, or during an unpaid lunch break can count toward overtime.

If they are paid at different hourly wages, that can affect overtime as well.

Be sure to know the minimum wage and payday laws for where your employees are working. You can meet the federal overtime requirements, but may still owe overtime in your state.

Take time to review your deductions as well. There are many different types of deductions and some may have special requirements or be pre-tax.

Your software can calculate pay, but it can’t add time that wasn’t entered.

Keep Records You Can Actually Use

You want to be able to look at an employee’s payroll and figure out how they were paid.

Save your records that show hours, hourly wage, wages, deductions, and taxes. Keep track of your taxes that you deposited and copies of your tax returns. If anything is updated, note that change in your books.

You should keep your employment tax records for at least 4 years after the due date or when the tax was paid, whichever is later. There are also rules for keeping your payroll records, which may be longer depending on the state you operate in.

Don’t have all your payroll information open for the world to see. These records contain a lot of private information, so make sure only certain people have access to them. Make sure you have backups of your payroll records as well.

Having good records will help you answer questions about your employee’s pay.

Build a Payroll Routine That Catches Mistakes

Create a simple process that you can follow when running payroll each time.

In the Q4 2024 survey of small businesses done by MetLife and the US Chamber, 62% of respondents stated they spend a fair amount or great deal of time on payroll compliance each year.

Here are some steps you can use when running payroll:

  1. Pre Payroll: Collect time sheets, new hires, any pay increases and deductions.
  2. During Payroll: Check that each employee’s gross, taxes, and net look correct. Dig deeper if anything looks off.
  3. Post Payroll: Save a copy of your payroll report and reconcile your payroll to your books.
  4. Tax Due Dates: Make sure you have deposited your taxes and reported them on your tax return when due.
  5. Year End: Reconcile your employee’s year end wages and taxes and create your employee wage statement.

If you are using an accountant or payroll company, make sure you have a plan in place for who will approve, pay, and handle notices you receive from filing.

Remember to update your process if you hire someone in another state or if you start paying someone differently.

Wrapping It Up

By having these tips in mind, you will be prepared to avoid issues with your payroll. Make sure your workers are classified correctly, calculate their pay properly, stay on top of your taxes, and keep your records organized.

Once you know these basics, e-filing your W-2’s will seem less daunting when you have all your payroll information for the year in front of you.